Why hiring managers should look beyond first impressions to identify high-potential candidates
Even experienced hiring managers can overlook exceptional candidates when they rely too heavily on traditional job interviews. According to Wharton organizational psychologist Adam Grant, employers can improve their hiring decisions by focusing on how candidates perform in realistic work situations and how they respond to feedback.
In a traditional interview, candidates may be judged on confidence, communication style, eye contact, or how well they present their past experience. However, these qualities do not always reflect their ability to succeed in a particular role. A candidate who struggles in an interview may demonstrate outstanding skills when given the opportunity to perform a task that closely resembles the actual job.
Grant recommends two practical changes to the interview process:
1. Evaluate candidates through real-world challenges.
Rather than relying exclusively on interview questions and resumes, employers should give candidates a relevant work-related exercise. Depending on the position, this might involve solving a business problem, presenting a strategy, analyzing data, or demonstrating technical expertise. These exercises allow hiring managers to assess problem-solving, adaptability, communication, and job-specific abilities more directly.
2. Give candidates an opportunity to learn and improve.
A candidate’s initial performance may not tell the whole story. Providing constructive feedback and an opportunity to try again can reveal how quickly someone learns, adapts, and applies new information. This approach helps employers recognize growth potential that might otherwise go unnoticed.
What This Means for Life Sciences Hiring
For pharmaceutical, biotechnology, medical device, diagnostics, and other life sciences organizations, identifying the right talent requires more than matching a resume to a job description. Employers need professionals who can navigate complex challenges, collaborate across functions, adapt to changing priorities, and grow alongside the business.
A thoughtful interview process that combines structured questions with relevant work assessments can help hiring managers make more informed decisions. It can also uncover candidates whose abilities and potential may not be immediately apparent during a traditional interview.
The takeaway: Better hiring starts with better evaluation. By looking beyond first impressions, assessing job-related skills, and recognizing a candidate’s capacity to learn, organizations can improve talent selection and make stronger long-term hiring decisions.
At The Bandish Group, we believe successful recruiting is about finding the right fit—not simply filling a position. Our specialized life sciences executive search approach helps employers identify talented professionals whose experience, capabilities, and potential align with their organization’s needs.
Click here to read the entire article.